PUBLISH
Policy Analyses
-
China’s Outward Foreign Direct Investment: State of Play and Implications
This study examines the trends and forms of China’s ever-growing outward foreign direct investment (OFDI), and provides a case study as well as a business performance analysis on OFDI of major Chinese companies.China’s OFDI has ..
Wolla Park and Eui-Hyun Choi Date 2011.12.30
Overseas direct investmentDownloadContentSummaryThis study examines the trends and forms of China’s ever-growing outward foreign direct investment (OFDI), and provides a case study as well as a business performance analysis on OFDI of major Chinese companies.
China’s OFDI has increased rapidly in recent years, making China the World fifth largest investing country in 2010. The outbound M&A by Chinese companies constituted 42.4% of the total OFDI in the same year. Although the majority of China’s OFDI was still concentrated in the energy/natural resources sector of certain Asian and African countries, M&A-based investment in technology, brands, and distribution networks of the US, EU, Japan and other developed countries has showed an upward trend.
China’s investments in developed countries (except Canada where China’s investments are natural-resource-oriented) are motivated mainly by companies’ market-seeking and technology acquisition strategies. As for investments in developing countries, they are basically aimed at natural resources and market penetration. In particular, while most of China’s OFDI in Africa was in natural resources (except South Africa where market-seeking OFDI prevailed), OFDI in ASEAN countries was mainly oriented towards entering their markets. The level of Chinese investment in Korea is marginal in comparison to bilateral trade volume between the two countries. China’s investment here is concentrated in the manufacturing sector, followed by services, and characterized by its small scale.
A case-study on OFDIs of major Chinese companies has revealed that their business performance was below expectation. Chinese companies present in Africa have suffered from poor investment environment there; Outbound M&A aimed at technology acquisitions in developed countries have failed due to the lack of management expertise of Chinese acquirers, resulting in worsened business performance of both Chinese adquirers and acquired companies. Representative examples are: M&A of France’s Alcatel by TCL, and M&A of Korea’s Ssangyong Motors and Hydis by Shanghai Motors and Jingdongfang Hightech respectively. Although those Chinese companies are powerful in their respective sectors, they have been engaged in M&A transactions with no account of their own capacities in technology, size, and management expertise. Moreover, Shanghai Motors and Jingdongfang Hightech were more interested in technology acquirement rather than improvement of the acquired company’s performance, which consequently worsened.
On the other hand, the acquisition of Korea’s Actoz Soft by Shanda, a Chinese online game company, is a success story of a relatively small-scale M&A which focused not only on the acquisition of the local company’s technology (intellectual property), but also the latter’s expansion and growth in the Korean market. Shanda’s case shows that China’s outbound M&A transactions in which size and technology level of acquired companies are modest enough to be controlled by Chinese acquirers tend to be more successful, rather than excessive large-scale M&As with Chinese government support. -
An Analysis of Environment Provisions in Free Trade Agreements and its Policy Implications
Over the last several years, the number of FTAs has significantly increased. Even if the basic aim of many FTAs is to cut tariffs, an increasing number of agreements deals with environment. While advanced countries, such as the Un..
Jeong-Gon Kim and Hyeyoon Keum Date 2011.12.30
Economic integration, Environmental policyDownloadContentSummaryOver the last several years, the number of FTAs has significantly increased. Even if the basic aim of many FTAs is to cut tariffs, an increasing number of agreements deals with environment. While advanced countries, such as the United States, the European Union and New Zealand, have included the most ambitious environmental provisions or chapters in FTAs, some developing countries also have made an efforts to include environmental provisions in their trade agreements. This is an ongoing learning process and countries can benefits from the previous experiences. Against this backdrop, this study examines environmental provisions in FTA texts of major countries including both advanced and developing countries, and addresses some key factors related to the environmental aspects of FTAs. Based upon these analyses, this study also reviews some policy implications for Korea's future FTA negotiations.
-
Regional Economic Integration in the Asia Pacific Region: Is an FTAAP the Catalyst for One Community?
In order to argue that the proposed FTAAP is the second-best policy option for APEC member economies and the world economy com-pared to the stalled first-best multilateral liberalization effort like the DDA (Doha Development Agend..
Sangkyom Kim et al. Date 2011.12.30
Economic integration, Economic cooperationDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Regional Economic Integration and FTAAP
1. Regional Economic Integration in the APEC Region
2. Conditions for a Desirable FTAAPIII. Feasible Scenarios for the Best Practiced FTAAP
1. Comprehensive Application of Tariff Elimination in Goods Trade
2. Liberalization of Trade in Services
3. Enhancing Trade Facilitation
4. Feasible Scenarios for the FTAAPIV. Measuring the Impact of FTAAP
1. CGE Model
2. Data
3. Simulation ResultsV. Concluding Remarks
References
SummaryIn order to argue that the proposed FTAAP is the second-best policy option for APEC member economies and the world economy com-pared to the stalled first-best multilateral liberalization effort like the DDA (Doha Development Agenda), we examine existing arguments for and against the proposed FTAAP. From our examinations, we find that the FTAAP is a sustainable RTA (Regional Trade Agreement) and will work as a stepping stone towards global free trade. In addition, the FTAAP will be a more desirable RTA if it is cooperated with the APEC’s principle of open regionalism or/and evolves to a customs union of the region. However, unlike traditional FTAs, the FTAAP has some APEC-specific impediments to its establishment of a regional trade bloc at present. Some policy recommendations would be proposed to overcome the obstacles. -
Measuring Arbitrage Costs from Relative Prices: Implications for the PPP Puzzle
This paper estimates the arbitrage costs from international relative prices, and studies the economic determinants of implied arbitrage costs. We find that the magnitude of arbitrage costs depends on the characteristics of both th..
In Huh And Inkoo Lee Date 2011.12.30
Financial policy, Exchange rateDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Direct Measurement of Arbitrage Costs
III. Arbitrage Costs and Relative Prices
IV. Empirical Analysis
1. Threshold Autoregressive (TAR) Model
2. ResultsV. Implications for the PPP Puzzle
VI. Conclusions
References
SummaryThis paper estimates the arbitrage costs from international relative prices, and studies the economic determinants of implied arbitrage costs. We find that the magnitude of arbitrage costs depends on the characteristics of both the type of good and set of locations under examination. More specifically, higher share of non-traded input and lower tradability of good lead to larger arbitrage cost, as does a lower proximity of geographic distance between locations. The role of location-specific characteristic in accounting for the arbitrage cost is more significant as we move beyond an economic geography, while good-specific characteristics matter relatively more if we move to the interior of this geography. We also show that arbitrage cost plays an important role in explaining the puzzling behavior of real exchange rate. We view our evidence as complementary to those that emphasize the role of nominal price rigidities.
-
Real Convergence and European Integration: What Factors Make the Difference in Growth at Regional Level?
This paper examines income convergence across Europe during the period 1995~2007 where the last enlargement of the EU and the process of economic integration was in active progress. It is generally accepted that the enlargement of..
Yoo-Duk Kang Date 2011.12.30
Economic development, Economic integrationDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Theoretical Argument of Convergence
1. Theoretical Development of Convergence
2. Previous Case of Convergence: Ireland, Greece, Spain and PortugalIII. An Assessment of Convergence Patterns in the EU-27
1. Measures of Convergence
2. Cross-country and within-country convergence in the EUIV. Empirical Test on the European Regions
1. Model Specification
2. Data
3. ResultsV. Conclusion
References
Appendix
SummaryThis paper examines income convergence across Europe during the period 1995~2007 where the last enlargement of the EU and the process of economic integration was in active progress. It is generally accepted that the enlargement of the EU has been followed by the convergence of late comers toward the European average. The author focuses on only the cross-county convergence, but also within-country convergence. He concluded that the remarkable cross-country convergence has tended toward within-country divergence, particularly for Central and Eastern European Countries during the enlargement period. Economic weights of the respective regions in national economies seem to be critical in explaining within-country divergence. High income regions, mostly capital cities, in CEECs are characterized particularly by higher growth rates. It is highly probable that the economic integration has favored those well-off regions at the expense of regions remote from their capitals.
This tentative conclusion provides important policy implications not only for European integration, but also for economic integration in other regions, where countries have been seeking diverse regional trade agreements (RTA). Economic integration is largely recognized as a policy option to boost economic growth through trade and investment channels, but economic benefits are likely to be concentrated in certain favored regions, mostly capital regions or industrial areas which have already been enjoying high income levels. Thus, it will be increasingly necessary to develop a mechanism to channel economic benefits to backward regions for within-country convergence. -
Strategic Trade Policy with Border Carbon Adjustments
This article further develops a framework of Brander and Spencer (1984) by adding Border Carbon Adjustments (BCA) to compensate for cost differences caused by emissions reduction among countries. On a level playing field, BCA is o..
Jeongmeen Suh Date 2011.12.30
Trade policy, Environmental policyDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Model
1. Setup
2. Stage 2
3. Stage 1III. Equilibrium Analysis
1. Position-dependent Best Responses
2. Equilibrium Carbon Taxes
3. Impacts of BCAIV. Discussion: Strategic Relationships between Home and Foreign Carbon Taxes
V. Concluding Remarks
References
Appendix
SummaryThis article further develops a framework of Brander and Spencer (1984) by adding Border Carbon Adjustments (BCA) to compensate for cost differences caused by emissions reduction among countries. On a level playing field, BCA is one-directional in that only a country with a more stringent carbon tax can impose BCA on its imports. In a two-stage game with a reciprocal market model, governments move first by choosing domestic carbon tax rate on their own firms. The level of BCA is determined by both home and foreign carbon taxes. Firms take taxes and BCA as a given and compete by choosing either output levels or prices. The right to impose BCA makes two countries unequal in that a country with the right can extend the influence range of its domestic carbon tax on imports while the other cannot. Besides equalizing carbon costs across countries, BCA changes the incentive structure regarding governments’ domestic climate policy choices, as governments try to maximize their countries’ welfare. Our findings are robust whether the competition is Cournot or Bertrand because the effect by BCA dominates the mode of competition. -
Can English Proficiency Boost International Trade in Services?
Recently, increasing numbers of financial MNEs are adopting English as their in-company official language. This paper attempts to investigate to what extent English proficiency, as the language of global business, can boost intern..
Kyounghee Lee Date 2011.12.30
Trade policyDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Empirical Methodology
1. Empirical Specifications
2. Data DescriptionIII. Empirical Results
1. Main Results
2. Robustness Checks
3. SimulationIV. Conclusions
References
Appendix
SummaryRecently, increasing numbers of financial MNEs are adopting English as their in-company official language. This paper attempts to investigate to what extent English proficiency, as the language of global business, can boost international trade in services. To achieve this purpose, this paper estimates the determinants of services trade including language variables with the aggregated and disaggregated data for nine different subsectors of OECD countries. The empirical model is based on a theory-based gravity model derived from Anderson and von Wincoop (2003, 2004). The findings show that English proficiency has a significant influence on services trade, while other languages such as French and German have only weak and mixed effects. In particular, communication, financial, commercial, insurance, and business services are revealed to be the most impacted by the level of English proficiency. The results imply that governments can use their English policies to promote international trade in services. -
A Quantitative Assessment of Credit Guarantee Scheme in Asian Bond Markets
This paper reviews current development of the Asian Bond Markets Initiative (ABMI) and addresses the macroeconomic effects of credit guarantee schemes through the Credit Guarantee Investment Facility (CGIF) along with the ABMI. Th..
Young-Joon Park and Dong-Eun Rhee Date 2011.12.30
Financial policy, Financial integrationDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Asian Bond Markets Initiative
1. Birth of the ABMI
2. Development of the ABMI
3. Credit Guarantee Investment FacilityIII. Model
1. Households
2. Production
3. International TradeIV. Quantitative Experiments
1. Scenarios of Credit Guarantee Schemes
2. Measuring the Size of Shocks
3. Simulation ResultsV. Concluding Remarks
References
Appendix: Trade Matrix
SummaryThis paper reviews current development of the Asian Bond Markets Initiative (ABMI) and addresses the macroeconomic effects of credit guarantee schemes through the Credit Guarantee Investment Facility (CGIF) along with the ABMI. The findings from international macroeconomic simulations include that (i) even though East Asian financial cooperation upgrades some countries’ credit fundamentals, it helps increase both the corresponding countries’ real GDP and East Asia’s regional real GDP, and (ii) this effect becomes greater as credit rating upgrade happens to more ASEAN+3 member countries in East Asia. These results strongly recommend that ASEAN+3 efforts along with the ABMI should move toward building local currency bond markets on the existing achievements. For the ABMI to be more effective, moreover, the importance of regional prudential supervision and regional market infrastructure is given with greater emphasis. -
Regional Difference and Counterfactual Decomposition of Pro-Poor Growth: An Application to Rural Ethiopia
Previous literature, ignoring regional heterogeneity, has mainly ex-plored the interrelationship among growth, inequality, and poverty. In exploring the incidence of poverty and growth, we classify rural Ethiopia into three region..
Sungil Kwak Date 2011.12.30
Economic development, Economic cooperationDownloadContentI. Introduction
II. Ethiopia Rural Household Survey and Poverty Profile
1. Data: Ethiopia Rural Household Survey
2. Poverty in Rural EthiopiaⅢ. Determinants of Poverty in Rural Ethiopia
IV. Pro-poor Growth Analysis and Counterfactual Decomposition
1. Pro-poor Growth and Growth Incidence Curve
2. Counterfactual Decomposition of Growth Incidence CurveV. Concluding Remarks
References
Appendix
SummaryPrevious literature, ignoring regional heterogeneity, has mainly ex-plored the interrelationship among growth, inequality, and poverty. In exploring the incidence of poverty and growth, we classify rural Ethiopia into three regions based on the difference of production technologies and climates. We find evidence that regional heterogeneity exists across the three regions. To find the sources of heterogeneity, we estimate a pseudo-fixed effect probit model controlling for household fixed effects within a random effect probit model across regions. We find that poverty is determined by different sources across the three regions, each with different farming systems. Moreover, poor households can escape poverty only when their expected level of well-being has been improved by increases in asset holdings and/or returns to assets. Hence, we propose, using counterfactual decomposition, that pro-poor growth can be decomposed into two components: changes in the amount of attributes such as observable household assets or capital, and changes in ‘aggregate marginal product’ of the attributes. We find that the impacts of the changes in the aggregate marginal product on pro-poor growth are significant in the hoe area, but the changes in attributes do not significantly affect growth in this region. The aspects of growth are determined heterogeneously across regions: in the highland area, both components work together; in the hoe area, growth is mainly determined by changes in the aggregate marginal product; and in the enset area, it is changes in attributes that mainly determine the positive growth. We find evidence that pro-poor growth in a relative sense appear in the hoe area, where the impact of changes in the aggregate marginal product on growth is heterogeneous along the income distribution; the larger impact appears in the lower tails, while smaller impact can been seen in the upper tails. However, we find no evidence of pro-poor growth in the highland and the enset areas, where the impacts of the aggregate marginal product on growth are anti-poor and insignificant, respectively. Therefore, since the impact of changes in productivity on growth differs across regions, technology disseminated to increase household productivity should be tested whether it could generate pro-poor growth in the recipient’s environment. For example, in providing agricultural technologies through the Korea Project on International Agriculture (KOPIA) or new knowledge via the Knowledge Sharing Program (KSP), we have to deliberate carefully on whether the knowledge and technology do indeed have pro-poor aspects. -
Analysis on the Competitiveness of Japanese Manufacturing Industry
This policy paper aims to analyze the competitiveness of Japanese manufacturing sector since the 1990s, focusing on the crisis of Japanese electronic sector, which is often called as the Galápagos Syndrome. Based on the ana..
Gyu Pan Kim et al. Date 2011.12.30
Economic development, Industrial policyDownloadContentSummaryThis policy paper aims to analyze the competitiveness of Japanese manufacturing sector since the 1990s, focusing on the crisis of Japanese electronic sector, which is often called as the Galápagos Syndrome. Based on the analysis, we derive various implications for the Korean manufacturers and the government from the Japanese experiences.
Chapter two reviews the factors that affected the competitiveness of Japanese manufacturing sector, for example, the rising of Asian emerging markets, the appreciation of Yen since Plaza accord of 1985, and the digitalization and standardization of manufacturing technology.
Chapter three analyzes the competitiveness of Japanese manufacturing sector since the 1990s using indexes such as Total Factor Productivity (TFP), Intra-Industry Trade Index (IIT), and Value Added Rate. According to the TFP measurement, It is clear that the productivity of Japanese manufacturing sector has fallen apparently from 1995. And, according to IIT measurement, the export competitiveness has weakened in electronics, general machinery, metal and textile industry. In particular, the Japanese manufacturing sector has lost its competitiveness by the ratio of value-added to sales amount which has fallen even during the depreciation of Yen in the 2000s.
Chapter four examines the crisis of Japanese manufacturing sector from the perspective of business management (in Japanese, Monozukuri). We are emphasizing that modularization of manufacturing architecture has deprived Japanese electronic manufacturing firms of comparative advantages based on integral manufacturing technology. Moreover, the earthquake in the northeastern Japan in March 2011 has revealed the fragility of Japanese manufacturer’s supply chain, which used to be considered as one of the major strong points.
Chapter five discusses the strategies and the polices of the Japanese government to strengthen the manufacturing sector. We are focusing on how the Japanese government supported the R&D sector with R&D Partnership and fostered the cooperation between the government, the industry and the academia. The Japanese government has tried to increase R&D expenditure, stabilize employment, and assist growth of ecological enterprises and small businesses. However, the Japanese government's polices have been ineffective in that its R&D expenditure has not contributed much to the profit growth of the enterprises, nor has the R&D Partnership induced active participation from many firms, not to speak of the unachieved innovation outcomes from the cooperation between the government, the industry, and the academia.
Chapter six discusses the lessons and the policy implications we could obtain from the Japanese experiences to strengthen the Korean manufacturing sector, so that the Korean manufacturing firms would not repeat the Japanese electronic manufacturer’s experiences. The Korean government should support the growth of the higher value-added industry such as parts and materials manufacturing sectors. Moreover, it is necessary for the Korean manufacturing firms to be more active in business cooperation with their Japanese counterparts, especially when expanding to the new emerging Asian markets. Finally, the Korean government should further actively engage in the R&D investment of the small businesses in basic science technology. In this respect, the Japanese R&D partnership and cooperation between the government, the industry, and the academia could be a good example for the Korean government.